
Can crisis-stricken Afghanistan be prevented from turning into an extremists’ sanctuary once more?
LONDON: Almost a 12 months into the Taliban’s return to energy in Afghanistan following the US navy withdrawal, there’s mounting concern that the bankrupt, unstable and internationally remoted nation might as soon as once more change into a sanctuary for extremist teams and even a launchpad for world terrorism.
The US beat a rushed retreat from Afghanistan in August 2021 after reaching a shaky peace take care of the Taliban, whose leaders pledged to by no means once more supply sanctuary to extremist teams akin to Al-Qaeda, which had plotted the 9/11 assaults from Afghan soil.
The hope was that Afghanistan wouldn’t change into a hotbed of worldwide terrorism because it had been in 2001, and {that a} plot for an assault of 9/11’s magnitude would by no means once more emanate from the nation.
However in widespread with thousands and thousands of Afghans, not many South Asian observers had been satisfied of the Taliban’s sincerity, believing as a substitute that the nation was being hijacked but once more by a violent and insular fundamentalist group.
“I do assume that Afghanistan has already change into a hive of terrorism,” Ahmad Wali Massoud, a former ambassador of Afghanistan to the UK, informed Arab Information.
“Already we are able to see many strands of terrorism, from Al-Qaeda to Daesh. They’re already staying inside Afghanistan, they’re being protected by the Taliban, they’re protected by the federal government of Taliban inside Afghanistan.”
Massoud is the youthful brother of Ahmad Shah Massoud, the Tajik guerrilla commander who till the Taliban’s return to energy final 12 months was feted as Afghanistan’s nationwide hero.
“The US departure from Afghanistan was very unrealistic, very irresponsible, it was not coordinated nicely, and ignored the folks of Afghanistan,” Ahmad Wali Massoud informed Arab Information.
“The US left their allies, the folks of Afghanistan, the safety forces of Afghanistan, which they helped for nearly 20 years. They fully ignored them. They left them alone to the mercy of terrorism, of the Taliban, of extremism.”
Right now, Ahmad Wali Massoud’s nephew, Ahmad Massoud, heads the Nationwide Resistance Entrance towards the Taliban in his native Panjshir, north of Kabul, the place his father had famously resisted the Soviets and the Taliban a long time earlier.
Latest preventing in Panjshir doesn’t nonetheless symbolize a problem to the Taliban’s management of Afghanistan, however it’s the most vital and sustained armed opposition the group has confronted since returning to energy.
For Massoud and others, the concept that, as soon as in energy, the Taliban would act much less like an rebel motion and extra like a authorities for all Afghans, was not fairly grounded in actuality.
With political violence now rife throughout the nation, freedom of speech curtailed, and the rights of ladies and women eroding steadily, war-weary Afghans’ temper is one among deepening pessimism.
Responding to the developments since final August, the US and world monetary establishments have frozen Afghanistan’s belongings, withheld support and loans, and sought to isolate the Taliban regime.

Because of this, the Afghan authorities is perpetually getting ready to financial collapse and, in some components of the nation, the specter of famine looms. Nearly half the inhabitants — 20 million folks — is experiencing acute starvation, in response to a UN-backed report issued in Could.
On Wednesday, the nation confronted a brand new humanitarian disaster when a magnitude 5.9 earthquake struck the nation’s east, killing greater than 1,000 folks and injuring one other 1,500. A lot of the deaths occurred within the provinces of Paktika, Khost and Nangarhar,
Moreover, the Taliban finds itself battling a violent insurgency led by Daesh’s native franchise, the Islamic State in Khorasan, or IS-Okay, which in latest months has repeatedly focused members of minority communities together with Shiites, Sikhs and Sufis.
A just lately launched UN report says IS-Okay has between 1,500 and 4,000 fighters, “concentrated in distant areas” of Kunar, Nangarhar and presumably Nuristan provinces. Based on the research, smaller, covert cells are positioned in northern and northeastern provinces, together with Badakhshan, Takhar, Jowzjan, Kunduz and Faryab.
Whereas the Taliban is glad with establishing an Islamic polity inside Afghanistan, the aim of IS-Okay is to create a single state for all the Muslim world, in response to students of political Islam.
IS-Okay is searching for to use dissension inside the Taliban ranks over whether or not the group ought to embrace pragmatism or ideological purity. The tensions are intensified by the hodge-podge of entities in Afghanistan, together with Daesh, the Pakistani Taliban and Al-Qaeda.
INNUMBERS
* 20m Afghans experiencing acute starvation.
* 1,000+ Loss of life toll of June 22 earthquake.
* 1,500+ UN estimate of IS-Okay fighters in Afghanistan.
The Taliban’s dilemma because it tries to control a rustic that has skilled 20 years of Western-led modernization was predicted by Kamran Bokhari in an op-ed in The Wall Avenue Journal on Aug. 27, 2021.
“The Afghan Taliban have to alter however can’t — not with out inflicting an inside rupture,” he wrote. “Such modifications … require a protracted and tortuous course of, and even then, transformation stays elusive.
“The danger of fracture is particularly acute when a motion has to alter conduct abruptly for geopolitical causes.”
On the one hand, the variety of bombings throughout Afghanistan has dropped since final August and Taliban 2.0 can’t be accused of instantly sponsoring terrorism. Then again, the following collapse of state authority in some rural areas and the lack of Western air assist for counterinsurgency operations have been a blessing to extremist teams.
“The Taliban takeover has benefited militant teams in a number of methods,” Michael Kugelman, deputy director of the Asia Program and senior affiliate for South Asia on the Wilson Heart, informed Arab Information.
“It has galvanized and energized an Islamist extremist community for which the expulsion of US troops from Muslim soil and the elimination of US-aligned governments are core targets. The takeover has additionally introduced into energy a gaggle with shut ideological and operational hyperlinks to a variety of militant teams.
“This implies on the very least that the Taliban received’t attempt to expel these teams from Afghan territory, and within the case of the one group that it’s concentrating on, IS-Okay, it lacks the self-discipline and capability to undertake cautious and efficient counterterrorism techniques.
“On a associated word, the Taliban lack the capability to function air energy, which had been the primary means utilized by NATO forces and the Afghan navy to handle the IS-Okay menace. Moreover, the Taliban has no capacity to ease an acute financial disaster, and the widespread privation fosters an setting ripe for radicalization. This advantages the IS-Okay.”

Because the US withdrawal from Afghanistan, the worldwide neighborhood’s persistence has flagged and a spotlight has shifted towards the struggle in Ukraine and the alarming prospect of a direct confrontation between Russia and NATO states.
Kugelman believes the fear threats emanating from Afghanistan fell off the radar lengthy earlier than Russia invaded Ukraine in February.
“I’d argue that the world was letting the terrorism menace in Afghanistan fester nicely earlier than the Ukraine struggle, primarily as a result of the US had struggled to construct out the capability to watch and goal terrorist threats in Afghanistan from exterior the nation,” he informed Arab Information.
“This isn’t a giant downside now, provided that the menace shouldn’t be what it was once. But when this neglect permits the worldwide terrorism menace in Afghanistan to progressively develop again and the US and its companions nonetheless don’t have a plan, then all bets are off and there might be huge issues.”
To make sure, the scenario in Afghanistan continues to be very completely different from that of pre-2001, when all the Al-Qaeda management was primarily based within the nation as friends of Mullah Omar, the founder and then-leader of the Taliban.
Al-Qaeda and its then-leader Osama bin Laden had initially been welcomed to Afghanistan by Abdul Rasul Sayyaf, a Mujahideen chief, after bin Laden’s 1996 expulsion from Sudan.
In Afghanistan’s political and geographic isolation inherited by the Taliban, Al-Qaeda was in a position to freely plot its assaults towards the US.
In April 2001, only a few months earlier than 9/11 and his personal assassination by the hands of Al-Qaeda operatives, Ahmad Shah Massoud had addressed the European Parliament in Strasbourg, warning the West would pay a heavy value if it continued to permit extremism to fester in Afghanistan.
Does that fateful speech have any relevance to the present scenario?

“Whereas one ought to by no means be complacent, it’s secure to say the worldwide terrorism menace emanating from Afghanistan isn’t as critical right this moment because it was when Massoud issued his warning in 2001,” mentioned Kugelman.
“Al-Qaeda has change into a lot weaker and the one different group in Afghanistan with globally centered targets is a Daesh chapter that at the moment can’t venture a menace past the quick area.
“That mentioned, let’s be clear: With NATO forces out of Afghanistan and an Al-Qaeda-allied regime now in energy, the bottom is fertile within the medium time period for worldwide terror teams to reconstitute themselves — and particularly if we see new influxes of international fighters into Afghanistan that may deliver shock troops, arms, cash, and tactical experience to those teams.”
In exile in Europe, Ahmad Wali Massoud is satisfied that the Trump and Biden administrations made a grave error in deciding to barter with the Taliban and in withdrawing from Afghanistan.
Permitting the group to return to energy, he believes, will inevitably rework Afghanistan right into a terror heartland — a growth he’s satisfied, simply as his brother warned, will come again to hang-out the West.
“I feel, by now, they should have realized, after nearly a 12 months, that they’ve made a mistake, as a result of they know now that the Taliban is uncontrolled,” Massoud informed Arab Information.
“I do assume that if the scenario stays like this, they are going to pay a really excessive value. In fact, Afghanistan has already paid a really excessive value. However I’m fairly certain the US may also pay a really excessive value.”